A Jewish Bet Din Then And Now

By Brenda Howard


When it comes to converting to Judaism, it can often be a lengthy process, especially when converting from Christianity. In addition, all conversions must be approved by a Jewish Bet din. In ancient times, a Bet din was the primary building block of the Biblical law of Israel. Also known as the house of judgment, a Bet din is now defined as a rabbinical court for those whom practice Orthodox Judaism.

Bet dins are a court of law in the Jewish tradition which have the legal powers required to oversee religious matters. Whereas, Din Torah is a matter of litigation in local communities and Israel in which a Diaspora provides judgments based on various levels of authority.

Original courts were inspired by Jethro and Moses, the first men to be provided with such powers, then later affirmed by God whom gave a direct command to the Jews to establish officers and judges inside community gates. Whereas, the Torah also recommends that a ruler delegate powers of judgment to lower level courts.

In ancient Israel, there were three types of rabbinical courts. These included two smaller courts of 23 appointees, one having hierarchy over the other and one grand central court of 72 appointees. Whereas, communities with populations between 120 and 230 residents were required to have a Bet din of 23 appointees though final judgments were handed down by a local tribal court.

The Talmud and Mishnah distinguish the area in which a case is tried based on the severity of the infractions. Whether involving money matters, criminal acts or ritual offenses, a Bet din generally rules over all cases. As with other courts, those involving criminal acts often face tougher fines and penalties than lesser offenses.

Bet dins which existed in Medieval times and those of modern time are in theory a court of law overseen by laymen. In most cases, these laymen act as arbitrators to determine sentences for infractions. For, these individuals often have more power than others and are composed of experienced rabbis which have knowledge of Jewish law. Although, if an individual attends a training institute, preferably in Israel, it is possible to become a religious judge which has even power when it comes to handing down rulings in a Jewish court of law.

While an Orthodox Bet din requires a minimum of three men whom are knowledgeable in Jewish Law, these individuals can often be difficult to locate. As such, the law now provides that even one Orthodox Jewish man can establish a Bet din. In addition, as each community is required to establish a dedicated Bet din, communities can choose how many judges to place on the court.

Individuals selected to make up a Bet din need to be capable of instructing others with regards to Jewish law pertaining to the case at hand. While this is the case, rabbis do not necessarily have to have expertise in all areas of law, just that pertaining to an ongoing case or cases. For example, when reviewing and approving a conversion, the rabbi would only need to understand the laws necessary to complete the process.




About the Author: